What to Do When Your Car Accident Claim is Denied by Insurance

by | Mar 25, 2024

Experiencing a car accident can be difficult for not only accident victims but also for families and other dependents. Having your insurance claim rejected can add further feelings of uncertainty and concern about how to manage the costs of repairs, medical care, and other related expenses that have been incurred due to the crash. It’s important to understand the reasons why your claim has been denied and the actions you can undertake to not only challenge the decision, but to also protect your rights and pursue the compensation you may be fully eligible to receive.

In this article, we’ll review some common reasons why auto accident insurance claim are denied and provide some helpful, actionable advice to work towards resolving the issue in your favor.

Table of Contents

What To Do If Your Insurance Claim Is Rejected After An Accident

If your claim has been denied by your insurer, listed below are some proactive steps to consider:

  • Examine the Denial Notice: First, review the notice you received from your insurer detailing why your claim was denied. This document is key to understanding their rationale and planning your response.
  • Compile Supporting Evidence: Assemble all relevant evidence that helps to reinforce your claim. This may include accident scene photos, statements from witnesses, police reports, medical documentation, and estimates for vehicle repairs. Such evidence can be very helpful in challenging the denial.
  • Communicate With Your Insurer: Reach out to your insurance provider for a detailed explanation of the denial. This is an important step as it can provide you with more insight as to why the claim was denied and, help serve as a guide while you prepare for a possible appeal.
  • Consider Filing an Appeal: Should you find the denial unfounded or based on incorrect facts, strongly consider filing an appeal. Use the guidance in your denial notice to help build your case the appeal and be sure to present any new evidence that further supports your case.
  • Get Legal Consultation: For those unsure of how to proceed or facing obstacles during the appeal, getting advice from a lawyer experienced in insurance and car accident claims is beneficial. A legal professional can offer expert advice and advocate on your behalf and most accident lawyers work on a contingency fee basis which means there are no upfront costs to you and they only get paid if they win your case.
  • Investigate Alternative Avenues: If your appeal doesn’t lead to a reversal of the decision, other avenues might still be available, such as filing a grievance with your state’s insurance regulator, seeking arbitration or mediation, or initiating legal action against the insurer.

Taking these measures and obtaining the right support can significantly enhance your chances of successfully contesting the denial and securing the compensation you deserve following a car accident.

Need help reviewing a claim? Contact us today.

Back To Top

Understanding a Claim Denial Letter

A claim denial letter is a formal message sent by an insurance company to inform a policyholder that their claim submission has been rejected. Such a letter usually explains why the claim was not accepted and often references specific policy conditions, exclusions, or other pertinent reasons that influenced the decision. These letters are important as they not only provide feedback to policyholders for the reason why the claim was rejected – they also often outline possible next steps, including how to challenge the decision or submit further evidence to support the claim.

Claim denial letters are an important link in communication, helping both the insurer and the insured understand the claim’s current status and the potential for any subsequent actions.

Back To Top

Common Reasons Why Auto Accident Insurance Claims Are Denied

There can be several reasons why a car insurance claim might be denied, including:

  • Exclusions in the Policy: Certain exclusions within your insurance policy might preclude coverage for specific accidents or damages, leading to a claim denial if your situation falls under these exclusions.
  • Inadequate Coverage: If your insurance policy does not cover the type of damage or injury incurred, your claim might be denied. An example would be lacking collision coverage while only having liability insurance, which wouldn’t cover personal vehicle damage.
  • Unmet Policy Conditions: Failing to adhere to the insurance policy’s stipulations, like promptly reporting the accident or submitting necessary claim documentation, can result in a denial.
  • Contested Fault: Claims can also be denied if there’s uncertainty or contention over who is to blame for the accident. This is common in accidents where fault is not immediately apparent.
  • Pre-existing Vehicle Damage: A claim may be rejected if the insurer believes the damage predated the accident or was not caused by the accident itself.
  • Allegations of Fraud: Providing inaccurate information or misleading the insurer about the accident circumstances or damage can lead to a denial on fraud grounds.
  • Lapsed Coverage: A lapsed policy due to non-payment or not having active coverage at the accident time can lead to claim denial.
  • Exceeding Policy Limits: If the claim amount surpasses your coverage limit, the insurer may refuse to pay beyond the maximum policy limit, denying any excess claims.

After a denial, there are usually avenues available for appeal or to seek other forms of recompense. Speaking with a knowledgeable Cincinnati car accident lawyer can help to provide insight into your legal options and advise the next steps to take following a denied insurance claim.

Have some questions?
We can help you find answers.

Back To Top

What Are Some Financial Compensation Options After an Accident with an Uninsured Driver?

If an uninsured driver was involved in your car accident and your insurance claim got denied, don’t lose hope. There are still several paths you might take to obtain compensation for your losses. Some options include:

  • Check Your Insurance Coverage: First, look into your insurance policy for uninsured motorist coverage. This type of coverage is specifically for situations where the at-fault driver lacks insurance or doesn’t have sufficient insurance to cover your costs.
  • File a Claim for Uninsured Motorist Coverage: Should you have this coverage, proceed to file a claim with your insurer, supplying all necessary documents like police reports, medical documentation, and estimates for repairs to back up your claim.
  • Try Mediation or Arbitration: Disagreements over the claim can sometimes be settled outside of court through mediation or arbitration. These are less formal ways to reach an agreement and can save time and resources.
  • Get Legal Advice: If you’re facing difficulties with your insurance provider over your uninsured motorist claim, speaking with a lawyer experienced in insurance disputes might be beneficial. They can assess your situation, deal with the insurer on your behalf, and guide you through the legal steps if needed.
  • Pursue a Lawsuit: In cases where the insurance company denies your claim or offers an unsatisfactory settlement, legal action might be necessary. An attorney can evaluate whether suing the uninsured driver or exploring other compensation methods is in your best interest.

Actively pursuing these options and consulting with legal experts can aid in securing the compensation you deserve following an accident with an uninsured driver.

Back To Top

Does Submitting an Insurance Claim Affect My Auto Insurance Premiums?

It’s possible that filing an insurance claim may lead to an increase in your insurance premiums, but this outcome depends on various factors such as the nature of the claim, the policies of your insurance provider, and your own history with insurance claims. Some considerations include:

  • History of Claims: Insurers review how frequently you’ve made claims in the past when setting the premium for a policy they issue. A pattern of numerous claims over a short time may result in higher premiums, whereas a single claim might not significantly affect premiums for someone with a generally clean claims record.
  • Who’s at Fault: There’s a distinction between claims filed for accidents where you’re at fault versus those where you’re not. At-fault claims are more likely to lead to increased premiums, whereas not-at-fault claims might not affect your premiums as much, depending on the insurer’s policies.
  • Nature and Severity of the Claim: The type of claim and the extent of the damages or liabilities involved can also play a role in whether and how much your premiums might increase. More severe incidents generally lead to bigger hikes in premiums.
  • Differences in State Rules: Since insurance laws vary by state, where you live can influence premium adjustments after a claim. Some states limit how much your premiums can increase after a claim, and others may forbid premium increases for accidents you didn’t cause.
  • Insurer’s Guidelines: Each insurance company has its own methods for adjusting premiums post-claim. Some might offer features like accident forgiveness, or loyalty benefits that can help soften the blow of a premium increase after a claim.

If the damage is minor, you might find it more economical to pay for repairs yourself to avoid a bump in your premiums. For more substantial damages or injuries, claiming may be necessary to cover your costs. It’s smart to talk over the potential effects on your premiums with your insurer before deciding to file a claim. Additionally, consider consulting an auto accident lawyer for advice tailored to your situation.

Get connected to a trusted local attorney.
No upfront fees. Learn more.

Back To Top

Can You Challenge a Denied Car Insurance Claim?

Absolutely. If your car insurance claim has been rejected, you’re entitled to contest the decision. Here are several strategies to aid in your appeal:

  • Analyze the Denial Notice: Begin with a thorough examination of the denial notice sent by your insurer. It will list the reasons your claim was refused and guide you on how to proceed with an appeal. Understanding why your claim was denied is vital for preparing your rebuttal.
  • Compile Supporting Evidence: Assemble all pertinent evidence and documentation that reinforces your claim. This could include accident photographs, statements from witnesses, police reports, medical documentation, quotes for repairs, and any other relevant data. Ensure your response directly addresses the insurer’s reasons for the denial.
  • Initiate the Appeal: Contact your insurance provider to start the appeal, adhering to the guidelines mentioned in the denial notice. Be ready to submit any additional documentation or details required by your insurer.
  • Present Your Case: Draft an appeal letter that clearly articulates why your claim merits approval. Include all evidence that supports your stance and counter any issues the insurer highlighted in their denial. Aim for clarity, objectivity, and courtesy in your letter.
  • Maintain Communication: After lodging your appeal, keep in touch with your insurance company to verify the progress of your case. Respond promptly to any requests for further details or clarifications.
  • Seek Expert Advice: Should you face difficulties during the appeal or need guidance, it might be worthwhile to consult with a lawyer experienced in insurance disputes. A legal expert can provide valuable advice, represent your interests, and potentially help reverse the denial.
  • Look Into Additional Recourses: If the insurer still denies your claim after the appeal, consider other avenues such as lodging a complaint with your state’s insurance regulatory body or taking legal action against the insurer.

Although facing a denied insurance claim can be daunting, actively pursuing an appeal with the right preparation can enhance your likelihood of securing the compensation you deserve.

Searching for a lawyer? We can help.

Back To Top

Should You Hire a Lawyer To Help Dispute a Denied Car Insurance Claim?

The decision to hire a lawyer after your car insurance claim has been denied can vary based on several factors, including how well you understand insurance regulations, the complexity of your claim, and how comfortable you are with handling the appeals process on your own. Some points to consider:

  • Knowledge of Insurance Regulations: For those well-versed in insurance policies and confident in self-representation, navigating the appeal might be manageable without legal help. However, if you’re unsure about the intricacies of insurance law or your rights, getting a lawyer’s advice can be crucial.
  • Case Complexity: Intricate cases involving substantial claims, legal challenges, or multiple parties might necessitate a lawyer’s insight. An attorney can dissect the specifics of your denial and devise a solid plan to counter the insurer’s decision.
  • Strategizing Your Appeal: Lawyers are adept at identifying the best tactics for appealing a denial. They can scrutinize the insurer’s reasoning, collate supportive evidence, and guide you on the most effective path forward, whether it’s negotiation, mediation, or litigation.
  • Ensuring Adequate Compensation: Insurers often propose lower settlements, banking on policyholders’ acquiescence. A seasoned lawyer can argue for a fair settlement that covers all your entitled damages, from medical bills and lost income to compensation for pain and suffering.
  • Stress Reduction: Contesting a denied claim can be daunting and exhaustive, especially if you’re recuperating from accident-related injuries. Hiring a lawyer can help to reduce this anxiety, knowing that you have an expert on your side.

Deciding to seek legal counsel for a denied insurance claim is a personal choice that depends on your specific situation and how confident you are in dealing with legal matters. A consultation with a lawyer can help to highlight your options and assist you to make a well-informed decision on how to contest the denial.

If you’re leaning towards legal assistance, Injury Law Support is here to connect you with proficient local car accident attorneys. Complete the “Free Case Review” form on this page, and a lawyer from our extensive network will reach out to discuss your case at no initial cost to you. If they accept your case, there are no upfront fees for their services as they work to secure your compensation.

Contact Injury Law Support today.

Back To Top

Free Case Review

No Upfront Fees. No Obligation.

"*" indicates required fields

Zip Code*